CSM Insights - Your Pathway to Strategic Automotive Planning
YOUR PATHWAY TO STRATEGIC AUTOMOTIVE PLANNING
First Quarter · 2008

Automotive Industry Emerging Markets

The Bear Among the BRICs

By Walt Madeira and Andrew Wright

Click to Enlarge Among the emerging-market BRICs countries (Brazil, Russia, India and China), it is now Russia that has become a hot topic in the automotive world and most other economic domains. Most spectators expect very strong growth of the Russian economy in the foreseeable future, and this, along with newly liberated and enriched consumers, should herald big opportunities in this massive, hitherto underdeveloped market. With numerous foreign carmakers setting up in Russia, the big question everyone asks CSM is: When will Russia become a major exporter of vehicles to the rest of the world?

New-vehicle demand in Russia is positively astonishing, and the race for one of the world's largest vehicle markets is well and truly underway. The most populous country in Europe is quickly living up to the title of vehicle market of the future due to its enormous growth potential. As a result, this paradisiacal marketplace offers global car manufacturers a new opportunity to gain tremendous volumes and reshape or solidify their future position with regards to the global vehicle rankings.

A few years ago, new-car sales volumes reached 1.5 million units over a one year period, just under half the levels normally achieved by Germany, the region's numberone vehicle market. In 2007, approximately 2.5 million vehicles will be sold in Russia, representing a 1-million unit incremental sales volume in just two years. On the other hand, German vehicle sales are struggling to maintain volumes steady at 3.5 million units, despite the positive indicators unleashed by a healthy economy. Russian consumers are increasingly wealthier and
demanding the latest vehicles to fulfill their personal dream of being able to afford a car. By 2013, the Russian market is expected to position itself directly behind Germany, within striking distance of claiming the title as Europe's number-one vehicle market. Russian consumers would proudly welcome this important role, which also heightens the possibility of heavily influencing future vehicle design both externally and internally. However, the future car manufacturers to spearhead the industry will surely not include many present-day Russian automakers if the current industry settings continue to run its course. The retreat of the three-letter Russian brands is a deep-rooted trend and a significant level of financial investment is desperately needed to halt the snowball effect.

A serious commitment is critical to ensure the renewal of domestic product offering and the resulting technological requirements. Russian consumers are increasingly wealthier and demanding the latest vehicles to fulfill their personal dream of being able to afford a car. Also, the opening of the credit market has lured aspiring buyers towards the means needed to achieve their ends. Foreign carmakers have been very quick to capitalize on this opportunity and will strengthen their position underpinned on significant rising sales levels.

At best, indigenous light-vehicle manufacturers will be able to tread water in the next few years. The majority of growth is expected from foreign brands, either domestically produced in one of the raft of new plants littering the Russian landscape or imported.

By 2013, most of the new-domestic producers will be getting into their stride, but the volumes we forecast for Russian production will still trail somewhat behind sales estimates. Several of these new entrants' plans for the market are rather conservative and cautious in comparison with recent new plants built in, for example, Central Europe. For this reason, it is still too early to talk about Russia becoming a major exporter of vehicles.

Magna International, a global supplier showing a high-profile interest in Russia by co-operating with local automakers VAZ and GAZ, as well as agreeing to build a vehicle assembly plant of its own, is expected to become one of the larger players. However, it is as yet unclear exactly what form the participation of Magna in Russia will take. Firstly, Magna was to build a new plant and help VAZ develop a brand-new model, the C; then the plant was cancelled. Co-operation with GAZ is shrouded in mystery and then the company agreed to build a plant in Russia in time to meet the favourable Decree 166 tariff regulations deadline in 2007, but it is not yet known whose vehicles the plant would build.

Renault and Fiat are two carmakers that have both signed Memoranda of Understanding with VAZ, the largest indigenous car builder. Once again the exact detail of the co-operation is still to be decided, but we expect VAZ to benefit at least from a platform share for the C project on the Renault/Nissan B platform that also houses the Dacia/Renault Logan. Powertrain is another area in which technology-sharing is a possibility. However, we wonder what benefits Renault gains from this partnership with a share of only 25% and the ever-present risk of fast-changing government policy.

On the supplier side, we expect some developments with Western and Asian suppliers setting up facilities in Russia, but we do not foresee this being huge within our forecast horizon of 2013-2014. Principal reasons for hesitation include: a lack of critical-volume mass; worries about government unpredictability and bureaucracy; poor infrastructure and logistics; and the presence of facilities in neighbouring Central Europe, where risk is also lower and existing OEM plants already provide steady work.

There is clearly massive potential for both sales and production of vehicles in Russia, with a huge untapped market that is being swiftly liberated and enriched. However, we feel that if the country does become a large-scale exporter of vehicles to the West and to Asia, it will not be before the end of the next decade at the earliest for the reasons explored above.

Walt Madeira and Andrew Wright may be reached via Email at WaltMadeira@csmauto.com and AndrewWright@csmauto.com.


DETROIT   GRAND RAPIDS   FRANKFURT   LONDON   PARIS   SHANGHAI   TOKYO   SÃO PAULO   BUDAPEST   DELHI   BANGKOK   SEOUL
HOME SITE MAP TERMS OF SERVICE AND USE PRIVACY POLICY © CSM WORLDWIDE ALL RIGHTS RESERVED